Revision history
BetMakers: an 11.6% spread that waits on the ACCC
Each revision is stored as published and never edited. Its sha256 is the hash of the canonical JSON below (UTF-8, exactly as shown), so anyone can check that a revision has not been rewritten. See how to verify.
Revision 216 Nov 2026 14:45 AEDT
sha256 e335e3c8ef480fa7f4e936b5827dc2bedc661825c352486a4b65b9f5df698006
Canonical JSON
{"v": 1, "rev": 2, "slug": "betmakers-11-6-spread-is-a-72-market-probability-the-accc-is-the-main-condition", "title": "BetMakers: an 11.6% spread that waits on the ACCC", "author": "u_033bd2603c", "note_id": "63eda47f-ff47-40a2-807a-c2d53f4aa87d", "tickers": ["BET"], "call_ids": ["be01db3b-ad6b-41a4-a84b-c78d7b2e74c0"], "markdown": "We are long BetMakers Technology Group (BET), a business-to-business (B2B) wagering-technology supplier, against CS200EW, the Capital Signal 200 Equal Weight index, for 120 trading days from 16 November 2026, entered at the **A$0.215** close of 13 November. Tabcorp Holdings' **A$0.24** cash scheme — a court-supervised takeover that binds all holders once approved — is **11.6%** above that price. The market implies **67–72%** completion depending on the break value, 72% on our central case; we put it at **85%**. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission's (ACCC) clearance of a vertical deal decides it. The scheme booklet and the report of the Independent Expert (IE), the valuer on whether the deal is in shareholders' best interests, are due late November or December.\n\n## Why the spread exists\n\nBetMakers closed at A$0.165 on 7 August, the last session before the Scheme Implementation Deed (SID, the binding takeover agreement) was announced. It closed the next day at A$0.22, up 33.3%, on 97.2m shares against 0.5m the session before. Since the announcement it has not closed above A$0.22 or below A$0.205. At A$0.215 the gross spread has ranged from 9.1% to 17.1% and sits at 11.6%.\n\nThe discount is not mainly a vote problem. No 5%+ holder has declared against the scheme in the filings we read. Harvest Lane Asset Management built from 5.31% to 6.45% to 7.47% on market after the SID, and Trium Capital entered at 5.47% on market; both are event-driven managers, funds that buy announced deals; neither has declared a vote. The directors' 9.97% is declared in favour. What the market is charging for is the regulatory chain, and the calendar.\n\nThe nearest comparisons are recent cash schemes. oOh!media's A$1.68 cash scheme with I Squared Capital, a US private-markets investor, was announced on 10 August, the day BetMakers signed; it has cleared the ACCC and the Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB), passed its vote on 2 November, and trades 0.3% below terms. Cleanaway's A$3.095 cash scheme with EQT Infrastructure, announced 19 October, still needs approvals in Australia, Kuwait and Saudi Arabia and trades 2.8% below terms. BetMakers' A$0.215 is 10.4% below the A$0.24 terms, an 11.6% gross spread, with the booklet still unwritten. The market is pricing a 28% failure probability on an approval process that has produced no adverse filing in the ASX record.\n\n## The deal\n\n| Term | Detail |\n|---|---|\n| Consideration | A$0.24 cash per share by default; scrip election of 25/50/75/100%, capped at 25% of total consideration, exchange ratio A$0.24 ÷ the higher of A$1.00 and Tabcorp's five-day volume-weighted average price (VWAP) |\n| Equity value | A$282.9m on 1,178,799,475 fully diluted shares (1,120,282,275 ordinary) |\n| Enterprise value | A$267.3m after A$15.6m net cash, which excludes A$22.2m of restricted cash |\n| Premium | 45.5% to the A$0.165 close on 7 August; 41.1% to the one-month VWAP |\n| Recommendation | Unanimous, subject to the IE and no superior proposal; directors holding about 10% intend to vote in favour |\n| Conditions | Shareholder approval by 75% of votes cast and a majority by number; court approval; an IE conclusion in favour; ACCC clearance; gaming, racing and regulatory consents. No financing condition, no Tabcorp shareholder vote, no further due diligence |\n| Break fee | A$2.83m each way, 1.0% of equity value, 0.25c per share |\n| End Date | 10 May 2027, nine months after the SID |\n| Timetable | Booklet and IE late November–December; scheme meeting targeted December 2026; completion targeted Q3 FY27 (January–March 2027) |\n\nThe scrip election is the main non-standard term: it is capped at 25% of consideration and priced off an A$1.00 floor.\n\nTabcorp is the ASX-listed wagering and media group behind TAB and Sky Racing. In FY26 (the year to 30 June 2026) it reported revenue of A$2,636.3m, EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation) before significant items of A$431.7m, net debt of A$533m and reported leverage of 1.2x, with A$1,161m of undrawn facilities and unrestricted cash. It is buying a supplier it already uses: BetMakers said in February that it \"…maintains an ongoing commercial relationship with Tabcorp, supplying wagering technology and content distribution services in support of Tabcorp's racing and media operations\" ([12 February 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03055794-2A1653272/pdf)). Record: the August SID is with that same counterparty. Chief executive Gillon McLachlan said the deal \"will accelerate our strategy across multiple areas\" ([Tabcorp announcement](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03119303-3A698445/pdf)). Record: the 30 October AGM repeated the Q3 FY27 completion target, and Tabcorp's FY26 accounts carry A$5.1m of transaction costs, so the bidder is spending behind it.\n\nThe strategic case is cost and speed. Tabcorp targets A$30m of run-rate cost synergies by the end of Year 2, and prices the deal at 6.1x FY26 EBITDA including the full run-rate. The cash bill is A$212.2m if the 25% scrip cap is fully taken and A$282.9m if nobody elects scrip, or 18–24% of Tabcorp's A$1,161m liquidity (our calculation). Funded from cash and facilities, pro forma leverage is 1.7–1.9x against a target of less than 2.5x (our calculation). There is no financing condition.\n\nThe scrip leg is worth less than the cash. Tabcorp closed at A$0.885 on 13 November, so the fixed exchange ratio of 0.24 shares is worth A$0.2124, 11.5% below A$0.24; at the 25% cap the blend is A$0.2331. Cash is the default and, at today's Tabcorp price, the only leg that pays A$0.24.\n\nBetMakers sells the plumbing, not the bet. Global Tote, the pari-mutuel (pooled) systems and international pooling business, was A$49.3m of FY26 revenue; Global Betting Services, which sells the Apollo platform, data and content, was A$43.3m. No customer was more than 10% of FY26 revenue and it operates in more than 30 countries. FY26 revenue was A$92.6m (+8.8%) and adjusted EBITDA A$14.1m at a 15.2% margin. Q1 FY27 was stronger: revenue A$24.7m (+16.3%), adjusted EBITDA A$5.9m at a 23.8% margin.\n\n## Break value\n\n| Break reference | Price | Downside from A$0.215 | Implied completion |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| Undisturbed close, 7 August 2026 | A$0.165 | −23.3% | 66.7% |\n| Small Ordinaries at measured beta 0.40 | A$0.1594 | −25.9% | 69.0% |\n| Small Ordinaries at beta 1.0 (used) | **A$0.151** | −29.7% | 71.9% |\n| ASX 200 move since 7 August (−1.96%) | A$0.1618 | −24.7% | 68.1% |\n\nWe use A$0.151. The measured beta produces a higher break, but it is measured before the bid, when the stock still moved with small caps rather than with the offer.\n\nThe Small Ordinaries fell 8.39% between 7 August and 13 November. BetMakers' beta to it over 126 daily returns from February to 31 July 2026 was 0.40 (our calculation from daily closes), which would put the break at A$0.1594. We use 1.0 because the pre-deal beta understates what happens on failure: the stock loses the bid that has held it between A$0.205 and A$0.22 and re-rates with small caps. The lowest close while the deal has been live, A$0.205, is above the undisturbed price, so it cannot be a break value.\n\nAt A$0.151 the enterprise value is A$153.6m on the 1,120.3m ordinary shares, 10.9x FY26 adjusted EBITDA and 6.5x the Q1 run-rate (our calculation). That is below the 12.0x the market paid before the bid, so the break assumes both a small-cap de-rating and no support from the run-rate.\n\n## Probability\n\nNo published ASX scheme completion base rate is available to us; our 85% is judgement, not a measured rate. The build below shows what it assumes. Our study of 953 fund-manager pitches from 2021 to 2025 found special situations returned a median −10.3% over 250 days against CS200EW, beating it 33% of the time. A binding cash scheme is a different bet: the upside is capped at the offer and the outcome is binary, so that prior does not transfer.\n\nWe start at 88% for this structure and take off 2 points for the ACCC's vertical-foreclosure question and 1 for the consent chain across 30-plus countries. That gives 85%.\n\nThe arithmetic. Gross spread: 0.24 ÷ 0.215 − 1 = 11.63%. Implied completion is 67–72% across the breaks above, 71.9% on ours. Expected value at 85%: 0.85 × 0.24 + 0.15 × 0.151 = **A$0.2267**, or +5.4% from A$0.215. At 80% it is A$0.2222 (+3.4%); at 90% A$0.2311 (+7.5%); the break-even probability is 71.9%. Our +5.4%, from the 13 November close to a mid-February 2027 completion (94 days), is about 21% a year, simple. At 31 March 2027 (138 days) it is 14.4%; at the 10 May End Date (178 days) 11.1%.\n\n## The gates\n\n| Gate | Date (and basis) | What we watch | Probability | What would tell us early |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| Booklet and first court | Late November–December (SID target for the meeting) | Orders to convene the meeting; dispatch of the booklet | 98% | An adjournment or a demand for supplementary disclosure |\n| ACCC | Before the meeting; no date filed | Clearance, or a statement of issues | 92% | Any ACCC publication that is not a clearance, or a move to a longer review |\n| Gaming and racing consents | Before the meeting; no date filed | A refusal, or a condition the parties will not accept | 97% | A scheme update naming a refused or conditioned jurisdiction |\n| IE | In the booklet | A conclusion against the scheme, or fair value below A$0.24 | 97% | The value range against the offer |\n| Scheme vote | December 2026 target; January–February our base case | The value test and the majority-by-number test | 97% | A named 5%+ holder declaring it will vote no |\n| Second court | After the vote | Approval without a late issue | 98% | A supplementary booklet or a timetable slip |\n\nThe ACCC is the least observable gate; the IE is the one that can end the scheme before the vote.\n\nThe product of the six is 81%. We hold 85% because a positive IE and ACCC clearance both lift the vote, so multiplying the vote gate again double-counts several points. The reconciliation is judgement, not arithmetic.\n\nThe regulatory position as filed: the SID requires \"clearance under Australia's mandatory merger control regime administered by the ACCC\". No determination, statement of issues, clearance or opposition appears in BetMakers' or Tabcorp's filings we read to 13 November. The 29 October quarterly says the parties \"…continue to progress the satisfaction of outstanding conditions precedent, including the relevant regulatory approval processes\", and Tabcorp's chair repeated the Q3 FY27 target at the 30 October AGM. We have not checked the ACCC's public register, so we cannot say whether an initial review is under way or whether a statement of issues has been published. That is the largest gap in this note.\n\nThe competition question is vertical. Tabcorp is a customer of BetMakers and a competitor of BetMakers' other bookmaker customers, so owning the supplier could foreclose rivals. A behavioural undertaking — a promise about how Tabcorp will deal with rivals — is the likely remedy if the ACCC engages. Timing precedent: Qube Holdings, a logistics group, moved its second court from 18 June to 7 July 2026 pending ACCC, FIRB and New Zealand's Overseas Investment Office approvals, after its scheme meetings had passed. The 10 May End Date leaves about six weeks beyond the end of Q3 FY27.\n\n## Register and vote\n\n| Holder | Shares | % at last notice | % of 1,120,282,275 | Declared intention |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| Matt Davey (executive chair), via Tekkorp Holdings, his controlled entity | 107,000,000 | 9.55% | 9.55% | In favour (SID) |\n| Simon Dulhunty | 3,973,620 | 0.35% | 0.35% | In favour (SID) |\n| Anna Massion | 498,339 | 0.04% | 0.04% | In favour (SID) |\n| Rebekah Giles | 243,134 | 0.02% | 0.02% | In favour (SID) |\n| Harvest Lane | 83,641,721 | 7.47% (9 October 2026) | 7.47% | None |\n| Trium Capital | 61,340,620 | 5.47% (9 October 2026) | 5.47% | None |\n| Form 603 group (2025 notice) | 58,091,346 | 5.3487% (16 June 2025) | 5.19% | Not checked |\n\nTwo event funds hold 12.94% and have declared nothing; the directors' 9.97% is the only declared yes.\n\n| Turnout | Votes needed for the value test (% of register) | No block that defeats | Undeclared 12.94% |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 50% | 37.5% of the register | Above 12.5% | Defeats |\n| 55% | 41.25% | Above 13.75% | Passes (yes 42.06%) |\n| 60% | 45.0% | Above 15.0% | Passes |\n| 70% | 52.5% | Above 17.5% | Passes |\n\nIf both event funds voted no, the scheme would still pass at any turnout above 51.8%, assuming every other vote is yes.\n\nThat threshold is the whole vote risk: Harvest Lane and Trium together sit just above the 12.5% that defeats the value test at 50% turnout and just below the 13.75% that would defeat it at 55%. The majority-by-number test is separate. We have not checked BetMakers' holder count or parcel sizes, so we cannot model it; the directors' 9.97% counts as four holders, which helps at the margin.\n\n## Valuation cross-check\n\n| Metric | BET at the A$0.24 offer | BET at A$0.215 | RAS Technology at the A$1.04 offer |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| Enterprise value | A$267.3m | A$237.8m | A$45.6m |\n| Enterprise value / FY26 EBITDA (statutory-derived) | **28.7x** | 25.6x | **20.3x** |\n| Enterprise value / FY26 adjusted or normalised EBITDA | 19.0x | 16.9x | 15.2x |\n| Enterprise value / annualised Q1 FY27 adjusted EBITDA | 11.3x | 10.1x | n/a |\n| Premium to undisturbed price | 45.5% | — | 93% |\n\nOn both the statutory and the companies' adjusted measures, the offer pays more for BetMakers than The Press Association paid for RAS Technology.\n\nRAS Technology, a racing-data and wagering-technology provider, is the closest comparator. Statutory EBITDA is profit before tax plus finance costs and depreciation and amortisation: A$9.3m for BetMakers and A$2.25m for RAS. BetMakers' adjusted figure adds back A$4.8m of share-based payments, restructuring, transaction costs and write-offs, which is why its adjusted multiple is 19.0x. RAS's normalised EBITDA is A$3.0m, so its normalised multiple is 15.2x. The A$0.215 enterprise value uses the fully diluted share count to match the offer. For context, Jumbo Interactive (lotteries) trades at 5.8x EBITDA and 11.5x earnings, Tabcorp at 5.9x underlying EBITDA, and PointsBet (a bookmaker) has negative EBITDA (our calculations). The standard industry group also includes Reef Casino, Ainsworth, SkyCity and The Star: casinos and gaming machines, not software.\n\nThe offer is 11.3x the Q1 run-rate and 58% above the pre-bid enterprise value of A$169.2m (our calculation). An IE testing standalone value would need to capitalise the Q1 margin as permanent to put fair value above A$0.24. That is the argument for the expert gate passing, and it is also why the break is not the offer: if the scheme fails, the stock can fall back toward A$0.165.\n\n## Comparable cash schemes\n\n| Deal | Structure | Announced | Status | Timeline | Spread |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| oOh!media / I Squared Capital (US private-markets investor) | A$1.68 cash | 10 August 2026 | Meeting passed 2 November; second court 18 November; implementation 10 December | 4 months | 0.3% below terms (99% implied) |\n| Cleanaway / EQT Infrastructure (private-markets investor) | A$3.095 cash | 19 October 2026 | Booklet and meeting not yet dated; approvals in Australia, Kuwait and Saudi Arabia open | Not yet dated | 2.8% below terms (89% implied) |\n| RAS Technology / The Press Association (UK media group) | A$1.04 cash | 19 October 2026 | Booklet early December; implementation February 2027 | 4 months | At terms (thin print) |\n\nThe same-day deal has only its second court left; the other two still have conditions to clear.\n\nThe timeline is the part that matters for the return. oOh!media took four months from announcement to implementation; RAS Technology expects four months to February 2027 with no ACCC condition. BetMakers is 98 days in with no booklet. A February meeting and a March completion would match those precedents; a May completion would cost about 10 points of annualised return.\n\n## What would change our mind\n\nAn ACCC statement of issues or a move to a longer review. A named 5%+ holder, particularly Harvest Lane or Trium, declaring it will vote no. An IE value range with A$0.24 below the bottom. A booklet that slips past February. Either event fund selling the stake it bought after the SID. A Tabcorp equity raise for the cash would also matter, though A$1,161m of liquidity makes it unlikely.\n\n## Sources\n\n- [Scheme Implementation Deed announcement, 10 August 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03119322-2A1688630/pdf)\n- [Tabcorp announcement, 10 August 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03119303-3A698445/pdf)\n- [BetMakers FY26 results, 31 August 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03128867-2A1693569/pdf)\n- [BetMakers FY26 annual report, 31 August 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03128848-2A1693526/pdf)\n- [BetMakers Q1 FY27 quarterly, 29 October 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03154892-2A1706828/pdf)\n- [Tabcorp FY26 results presentation, 26 August 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03126115-3A699805/pdf)\n- [Tabcorp AGM addresses, 30 October 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03155897-3A705447/pdf)\n- [RAS Technology SID announcement, 19 October 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03149739-3A704353/pdf)\n- [RAS Technology FY26 results, 27 August 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03127245-3A700052/pdf)\n- [Harvest Lane substantial holding, 9 October 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03146720-2A1703317/pdf)\n- [Trium Capital substantial holding, 9 October 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03146314-2A1703134/pdf)\n- [Jumbo Interactive FY26 results, 27 August 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03126829-2A1692430/pdf)\n- [PointsBet half-year accounts, 30 October 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03156353-3A705536/pdf)\n- [oOh!media ACCC determination, 24 September 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03139123-2A1698811/pdf)\n- [oOh!media FIRB approval and scheme result, 13 November 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03161549-2A1710495/pdf)\n- [oOh!media timetable update, November 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03156325-2A1707464/pdf)\n- [Cleanaway SID, 19 October 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03149797-3A704364/pdf)\n- [Qube further update on scheme, 15 June 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03100319-2A1677450/pdf)\n\n### What we couldn't check\n\nThe ACCC's public register, its review phase and any statement of issues; BetMakers' holder count and parcel sizes; the scheme booklet and IE (neither issued); the members of the 16 June 2025 Form 603 group and whether it still holds 5%; whether gaming and racing consent applications have been lodged; short interest and stock borrow; the exact date of the first court hearing.", "created_at": "2026-11-16T03:45:00.099Z", "evidence_doc_keys": ["2924-03119322-2A1688630", "2924-03154892-2A1706828", "2924-03128867-2A1693569", "2924-03128848-2A1693526", "2924-03055794-2A1653272", "2924-03146720-2A1703317", "2924-03146314-2A1703134"]}Revision 116 Nov 2026 09:25 AEDT
sha256 872679d8780ec48532b454198d0d20f45937e288170e26c76484bca07426c0f1
Canonical JSON
{"v": 1, "rev": 1, "slug": "betmakers-11-6-spread-is-a-72-market-probability-the-accc-is-the-main-condition", "title": "BetMakers' 11.6% spread is a 72% market probability; the ACCC is the main condition", "author": "u_033bd2603c", "note_id": "63eda47f-ff47-40a2-807a-c2d53f4aa87d", "tickers": ["BET"], "call_ids": ["be01db3b-ad6b-41a4-a84b-c78d7b2e74c0"], "markdown": "**BetMakers Technology Group Limited (ASX: BET)** · Consumer discretionary: B2B wagering technology and content · Public note, 16 November 2026 · Last close A$0.215 (13 November 2026)\n\n**The call.** The desk is long BET against the equal-weight ASX 200 for 120 days from the 16 November 2026 lock, with an entry reference of A$0.215. Tabcorp's cash offer is A$0.24, an 11.6% gross spread. The sector-adjusted break is A$0.151, a 29.7% loss. The market is pricing a **71.9%** completion probability; we put it at **85%**, which gives an expected value of **A$0.2267**, or +5.4%. The edge is thinner than it was in August because the small-cap index has fallen, not because the deal has weakened.\n\n---\n\n## 1. The deal\n\nTabcorp agreed to acquire BetMakers by scheme of arrangement for **A$0.24 cash per share** under a binding Scheme Implementation Deed dated 10 August 2026.\n\n| Term | Detail |\n|---|---|\n| Consideration | **A$0.24 cash** per share by default |\n| Scrip alternative | Up to 25% of consideration in Tabcorp shares, capped and scaled back; exchange ratio is A$0.24 divided by the higher of A$1.00 and Tabcorp's five-day VWAP before the record date |\n| Equity value | **A$282.9m** on 1,178,799,475 fully diluted shares |\n| Enterprise value | **A$267.3m**, after A$15.6m net cash, excluding A$22.2m of restricted cash |\n| Premium | 45.5% to the A$0.165 close on 7 August 2026 |\n| Recommendation | Unanimous, subject to the Independent Expert and no superior proposal; directors holding about **10%** intend to vote in favour |\n| Break fee | **A$2.83m each way**, 1.0% of equity value |\n| Exclusivity | No-shop, no-talk, no due diligence, with a fiduciary carve-out and a five-business-day matching right |\n| End Date | **10 May 2027**, nine months after the SID |\n| Conditions | Shareholder approval by 75% of votes cast and a majority by number; court approval; Independent Expert \"best interests\"; **ACCC clearance**; gaming, racing and regulatory consents in the jurisdictions where BetMakers operates. **No financing condition, no Tabcorp shareholder vote, no further due diligence.** |\n| Scheme meeting | Targeted for **December 2026**, not yet convened |\n| Completion | Targeted for Q3 FY27 (January–March 2027) |\n\nSources: [SID](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03119322-2A1688630/pdf), [Q1 FY27 4C](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03154892-2A1706828/pdf), [FY26 results](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03128867-2A1693569/pdf).\n\nTabcorp is already a BetMakers customer: BetMakers supplies it wagering technology and content distribution services under an ongoing commercial relationship ([12 February 2026](https://capitalsignal.io/api/filings/2924-03055794-2A1653272/pdf)). That cuts integration risk and raises the vertical-foreclosure question for BetMakers' other bookmaker customers — which is exactly the ACCC's lens.\n\n---\n\n## 2. The break value\n\nThe break is the pre-bid price, adjusted for the small-cap de-rating since the bid. BetMakers closed at **A$0.165 on 7 August 2026**, the last close before the SID. The Small Ordinaries fell **8.39%** from 3,527.7 on 7 August to 3,231.7 on 13 November. Applying that move gives **A$0.1512**, rounded to **A$0.151**.\n\n| Break reference | Price | Downside from A$0.215 | Implied completion at A$0.215 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| Unadjusted pre-bid close | A$0.165 | −23.3% | 66.7% |\n| **Sector-adjusted** | **A$0.151** | **−29.7%** | **71.9%** |\n| Sector-adjusted, ASX 200 move | A$0.1618 | −24.7% | 68.1% |\n\n**The only break used in the call is A$0.151.** The A$0.1618 figure is shown only to demonstrate why the small-cap index is the right benchmark: the ASX 200 fell 1.96%, the Small Ordinaries 8.39%, and BetMakers is a small-cap. The sector-adjusted break is the conservative one.\n\n**The spread arithmetic.**\n\n- Gross spread: A$0.24 ÷ A$0.215 − 1 = **11.6%**\n- Market-implied completion: (0.215 − 0.151) ÷ (0.24 − 0.151) = **71.9%**\n- Our probability: **85%**\n- Expected value at 85%: 0.85 × 0.24 + 0.15 × 0.151 = **A$0.2267**\n- Return from A$0.215: **+5.4%**\n- At 80%: A$0.2222, +3.3%\n- At 90%: A$0.2311, +7.5%\n- Break-even probability: **71.9%**\n\nThe market is at 72%; we are at 85%. The gap is the structure: a binding SID, a unanimous board, directors at 10%, a 1% break fee each way, a five-business-day matching right, no financing condition, no Tabcorp shareholder vote and no further due diligence. What is left is ACCC, gaming and racing consents, the court, the vote and the Independent Expert.\n\n---\n\n## 3. What has to happen, and what we watch\n\n| Condition | What we watch | When | Why it matters |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| **ACCC** | A public review, statement of issues, or clearance | Before the scheme meeting | The main merger risk. It is vertical: Tabcorp owning its supplier could foreclose rival wagering operators. A behavioural undertaking is the likely remedy if the ACCC engages. |\n| **Gaming and racing consents** | A refusal or an unacceptable condition in any of the 30+ jurisdictions | Before the scheme meeting | The condition is wide and the timetable is long. A single refusal can delay or stop completion. |\n| **Independent Expert** | \"Not in the best interests\", or a fair-value range with A$0.24 below the bottom | Scheme Booklet, late November–December 2026 | The board's recommendation is conditional on a clean IE. |\n| **Shareholder vote** | 75% of votes cast and a majority by number | December 2026 target | Directors 10% and event managers about 12.9% are supportive. The votes are there if the IE is clean. |\n| **Court** | Orders convening the meeting, then approval | First court before the booklet; second court after the vote | Standard scheme timetable. |\n| **MAC / trading** | 1H FY27 adjusted EBITDA | Late February 2027 | Q1 FY27 was a record (A$5.9m adjusted EBITDA, 23.8% margin). A reversal would support a MAC argument and lower the break. |\n| **Scrip** | Tabcorp's price at the record date | Before implementation | Below A$1.00 the ratio is fixed at 0.24 TAH shares; the scrip is worth A$0.2124 at Tabcorp's A$0.885 close, 11.5% below the cash. |\n\n**The register.** Davey/Tekkorp holds **9.55%**, Harvest Lane **7.47%** and Trium Capital **5.47%**. All are current notices. The old long-only register is gone: Paradice sold out two days after the SID, Tripp exited in 2025, and Perennial and Waterhouse exited in 2023. There is no disclosed 5%+ holder opposing.\n\n---\n\n## 4. The exit rules\n\nThe position is closed, not averaged, on any of the following:\n\n- **ACCC issues a statement of issues, opposes the acquisition, or the parties withdraw.**\n- **The Independent Expert concludes the scheme is not in the best interests**, or assesses fair value below **A$0.24**.\n- **The scheme meeting is adjourned beyond 10 May 2027**, the SID is terminated, or the End Date passes without effectiveness.\n- **1H FY27 adjusted EBITDA, due late February 2027, is below A$8.0m.**\n- **The price reaches A$0.227** — expected value at 85% on the adjusted break — without a new positive filing. At that level there is no edge left, so we take profit.\n- **A competing proposal emerges above A$0.24.** The desk would not sell into the A$0.24 bid; it would hold for the higher offer and reassess the break fee.\n\nThe position is sized at **3%**, with a maximum of 5%. This is a binary with a 29.7% break, not a core holding.\n\n---\n\n## 5. Risks specific to this deal\n\n1. **ACCC.** The main condition and the main timing risk. The theory is vertical foreclosure: Tabcorp is a customer of BetMakers and a competitor of BetMakers' other wagering customers. A statement of issues would likely take the stock back through A$0.19. No public review, statement of issues, clearance or opposition appears in BET's filings to 13 November.\n2. **Gaming and racing consents.** More than 30 jurisdictions, each with its own change-of-control process. The SID condition is broad, and a single unacceptable condition can delay completion.\n3. **The Independent Expert.** The offer is 6.1x post-synergy EBITDA and 7.2x the pre-bid run-rate. An IE could conclude the scheme is fair on market evidence and still note the standalone value is higher.\n4. **The vote.** 75% of votes cast is a high bar. Directors and event managers are supportive, but a large no vote from a single holder can defeat it.\n5. **Trading and MAC.** Q1 FY27 was a record quarter, but the company's long-term goals (10%+ revenue growth, 70%+ gross margin, 25%+ EBITDA margin) are goals, not guidance. A reversal would weaken the deal and the break.\n6. **Completion timing.** The return is 21.1% annualised at mid-February and 14.4% at 31 March. If the End Date is extended into 2H CY27, the trade stops paying.\n7. **Scrip.** Tabcorp at A$0.885 means the scrip is worth A$0.2124, 11.5% below cash. The 25% scrip cap limits the damage, but a holder who elects scrip is taking Tabcorp risk for a lower value.\n\n---\n\n## 6. Dated catalysts\n\n| Date | Event | What changes |\n|---|---|---|\n| **Late November–December 2026** | Scheme Booklet and Independent Expert | The IE conclusion and the ACCC/consent update |\n| **December 2026 (target)** | Scheme meeting | 75% of votes cast and a majority by number |\n| **Q3 FY27 (January–March 2027)** | Second court and implementation | Cash paid; the spread closes |\n| **Late February 2027** | 1H FY27 result | The MAC/trading test; below A$8.0m adjusted EBITDA is the exit |\n| **10 May 2027** | SID End Date | Hard backstop |\n\n**The one number we check first:** the ACCC's position. **The second:** the Independent Expert's conclusion.\n\n---\n\n## 7. What would make the call wrong\n\nThe call is wrong if the market's 72% is right and ours is 85%. That happens if the ACCC engages on foreclosure, if a gaming regulator refuses a consent, or if the Independent Expert finds the scheme not in the best interests. The first is the most likely; the second is the most mechanical; the third is the cleanest exit.\n\nIf the price reaches A$0.227 before a positive filing, the expected value at 85% is fully paid and the 29.7% break is no longer compensated, so we take profit rather than hold.\n\n---\n\nModel portfolio for research and education. General information only, not financial advice.", "created_at": "2026-11-15T22:25:11.245Z", "evidence_doc_keys": ["2924-03119322-2A1688630", "2924-03154892-2A1706828", "2924-03128867-2A1693569", "2924-03055794-2A1653272"]}